Don MacKeen reports.
[I]f there was one element that lent the conflict a tone
of the inauthentic and the invented, it was the swiftness with
which all values were forced in months to reverse themselves.
-Arthur Miller on the Anti-Communist witch hunt
of 1950s USA
Brian Souter is Scotlands richest man. With his sister,
Ann Gloag, Scotlands richest woman, he started Stagecoach,
which is now Europes largest transport company. Souter operates
buses throughout the UK, Sweden, Portugal, New Zealand, Australia,
Hong Kong, and the USA. He is in partnership with Virgin Rail,
he owns SouthWest trains and Supertram in Sheffield.
This very successful businessman built up his empire when Margaret
Thatcher deregulated the buses in the 1980s. The UK Monopolies
and Mergers commission has called his methods predatory,
deplorable and against the public interest.
In common with many successful businessmen in the USA, he is also
an evangelical Christian. When the Labour government announced
that, in accordance with its manifesto commitments it was going
to abolish a piece of Thatchers legacy - Clause 28 (called
2A in Scotland) which prevents the promotion
of homosexuality in schools - Souter decided to fund a campaign
to keep the legislation. He spent £500,000 - funnelled through
his charitable Souter Foundation - to fund an advertising
blitz and a poll. He sent 3,970,712 ballots throughout
Scotland asking whether people wanted to keep or scrap the clause.
While many people wrote letters to Scottish papers complaining
that they either got too many ballots or none at all, the poll
went ahead, with about a million Scots voting. 13.0%
voted against and 85.2% voted to keep the clause. However, 68/65%
did not take part, many boycotting the ballot (as Labour, the
Scottish Socialist Party and the STUC called for). Yet Souter
and his campaign declared victory, with the tabloid press (particularly
the Labour supporting Daily Record ) cheering him on. And the
government has caved into his pressure. Although Clause 28 will
be repealed, new guidelines will be brought in stressing
the importance of marriage. The whole fight was about
the promotion of homosexuality, yet Souter and his
followers are happy with the new language about marriage.
Gays have been stigmatised; now its the turn of the children
of single mothers.
So while Souter the privatised politician, didnt really
show the pro-Clause 28 faction were Scotlands silent
majority (as his ally, Cardinal Winning called them), he
has shown himself to be a force in Scottish politics. And, as
in America, his small band of right-wing Christians are going
to force debate and policy to bend to their doctrine. Only a concerted
effort by trade unionists, gay and lesbian organisations and socialists
will put a stop to it, and they should start first by educating
themselves on the activities of the evangelical movement
in the USA, and what it has achieved since it came to power along
with Ronald Reagan. Otherwise, this very organised and political
Christian force will continue moving east, maybe to
a city near you.
Ethics are not irrelevant but some are incompatible with
what we have to do, because capitalism is based on greed.
-Brian Souter
Don MacKeen is Spectres cartoonist. A US
citizen and member of the Socialist Party USA, he lives in Glasgow,
Scotland.